Taipei:A debate between a pro-nuclear lawmaker and a geologist opposed to restarting nuclear reactors highlighted differing perspectives on energy security, electricity costs, and earthquake risks during a televised presentation. This event took place ahead of Taiwan's upcoming referendum on November 28, which will determine whether to end the country's nuclear-free energy policy.
According to Focus Taiwan, the presentation featured Taiwan People's Party (TPP) Legislator Hung Yu-hsiang advocating for the proposal, while Wang Shou-cheng, from the Taiwan Geothermal Association, opposed it. This was the fourth of five presentations organized by the Central Election Commission regarding the referendum question on revitalizing the economy with nuclear energy and abolishing the "nuclear-free homeland" energy policy. The referendum is backed by the main opposition Kuomintang and the TPP, but opposed by the ruling Democratic Progressive Party (DPP).
During the presentation, Hung argued that nuclear power is crucial for providing stable, low-carbon electricity to meet the growing demands of Taiwan's semiconductor and AI industries. He criticized the DPP for not meeting renewable energy targets and allowing electricity prices to rise. Hung also expressed concerns about Taiwan's reliance on imported liquefied natural gas, highlighting the potential vulnerability to supply disruptions.
In contrast, Wang raised concerns about geological risks associated with nuclear power plants in earthquake-prone Taiwan, citing fault structures near the facilities. He questioned the feasibility and cost of restarting aging reactors, which may require extensive safety inspections and equipment replacements.
Taiwan's nuclear policy has been a subject of debate since the last operating reactor at the Maanshan plant was shut down on May 17, 2025, fulfilling the DPP's pledge to phase out nuclear power. However, recent developments, including rising electricity demand and geopolitical risks, have led to discussions on potentially restarting the reactors. The final presentation on this issue will feature pro-nuclear activist Huang Shih-hsiu and anti-nuclear spokesperson Teng Yu-yu.